I've griped before about how Canada is the only hockey country without an annual championship. It's now twenty years since a Canadian team won the Stanley Cup, and twenty-four since two Canadian teams faced off in the Stanley Cup final. Which clubs have been Canadian hockey champion since 1993? Who knows? In an earlier post I drew up a list based on regular season performance, or Stanley Cup win if that happened, and I awarded the St. John's Maple Leafs the championship during the lockout year, as they were the most successful Canadian pro team going that year.
Another way would be to look at who went deepest into the Stanley Cup playoffs. Starting with 1994 you get:
1994. Vancouver. (Stanley Cup final. 3 - 4.)
1995. Vancouver. (2nd round. 0 - 4.)
1996. Montreal/Winnipeg/Vancouver/Toronto. (All four were eliminated 2 - 4 in the 1st round.)
1997. Edmonton. (2nd round. 1 - 4.)
1998. Ottawa/Edmonton. (Both lost 1 - 4 in the 2nd round.)
1999. Toronto. (3rd round. 1 - 4.)
2000. Toronto. (2nd round. 2 - 4.)
2001. Toronto. (2nd round. 3 - 4.)
2002. Toronto. (3rd round. 2 - 4.)
2003. Ottawa. (3rd round. 3 - 4.)
2004. Calgary. (Stanley Cup final. 3 - 4.)
2005. ---------.
2006. Edmonton. (Stanley Cup final. 3 - 4.)
2007. Ottawa. (Stanley Cup final. 1 - 4.)
2008. Montreal. (2nd round. 1 - 4.)
2009. Vancouver. (2nd round. 2 - 4.)
2010. Montreal. (3rd round. 1 - 4.)
2011. Vancouver. (3rd round. 1 - 4.)
2012. Ottawa. (1st round. 3 - 4.)
2013. Ottawa.
Ranked: Ottawa 4.5. Toronto 4.25. Vancouver 4.25. Edmonton 2.5. Montreal 2.25. Calgary 1. Winnipeg .25.
I'm not saying break up the NHL. (Okay, well, yes, sometimes I do say that.) But what would be the harm in having a recognized method of pulling a top seed out of the stats? Would anyone object to another cup? The O'Brien Trophy perhaps?